Magistrate Judge Faruqui Dismisses Complaint Against Ex-FBI Officials Floris and Benavides for Lack of Probable Cause
A federal magistrate judge on Monday, Nov. 2, dismissed a criminal complaint charging two former senior FBI counterintelligence officials, Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides, with lying to Congress about their roles in the Hunter Biden investigation, CBS News reported. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui said the case lacked probable cause and appeared timed to the midterms: “no other event on the calendar, except for the midterm elections.” He said what had transpired “can’t be described as anything other than weaponization.” The Patel link comes from testimony, not the bench: FBI Special Agent Bryan Witt, assigned to help investigate, testified that the case was opened at the behest of FBI Director Kash Patel one day after Trump’s televised speech in July ordering prosecutions. The ruling followed a hearing of three days of testimony on the original complaint; Faruqui struck an unsigned and unsworn superseding complaint that prosecutors had filed after midnight to add obstruction charges. The Justice Department said it disagrees with the decision. The dismissal is of the complaint: the department could still appeal to the chief judge or seek a grand jury indictment.
The weaponization remark is the magistrate’s, from the bench; the Patel account is the agent’s testimony, not a finding by the judge. The ruling rests on a charging document and a preliminary hearing record, not a merits verdict on any charge. The case belongs with the prosecutions of the administration’s named adversaries recorded in 2025-09-25–james-comey-indictment-political-prosecution, 2025-08-22–fbi-raids-bolton-home-patel-directed and 2025-08-26–doj-weaponization-russia-investigators.
Correction (2026-11-16)
An earlier version said Judge Faruqui said the case was brought at the behest of FBI Director Kash Patel. CBS attributes that account to the testimony of FBI Special Agent Bryan Witt, who said the case was opened at Patel’s behest the day after Trump’s July speech. The judge’s own words, as CBS quotes them, are the “slapdash” case lacking probable cause, “can’t be described as anything other than weaponization,” and the midterm-timing remark. The written order was not in RECAP at the time of this correction.
Sources & Citations
The Cascade Ledger. “Magistrate Judge Faruqui Dismisses Complaint Against Ex-FBI Officials Floris and Benavides for Lack of Probable Cause.” The Capture Cascade Timeline, November 2, 2026. https://capturecascade.org/event/2026-11-02--magistrate-faruqui-dismisses-complaint-against-ex-fbi-officials-floris-benavides-no-probable-cause/