Supreme Court Holds in United States v. Miller That a Bank Depositor Has No Fourth Amendment Interest in the Bank's Subpoenaed Records

Opening

The Supreme Court decided United States v. Miller on April 21, 1976, after argument on January 12, 1976. The syllabus states the holding: “Respondent possessed no Fourth Amendment interest in the bank records that could be vindicated by a challenge to the subpoenas”. Justice Powell wrote that “The depositor takes the risk, in revealing his affairs to another, that the information will be conveyed by that person to the Government.” Justice Powell delivered the opinion of the Court, in which Chief Justice Burger and Justices Stewart, White, Blackmun, Rehnquist and Stevens joined. Justices Brennan and Marshall filed dissenting opinions, each its own.

Later cases describe this reasoning as the third-party doctrine. In Carpenter the Court wrote: “This third-party doctrine largely traces its roots to Miller.” Whether a government purchase of data from a commercial broker is a Fourth Amendment search is open; the Court has not decided it, and Miller did not involve a purchase. See fourth-amendment-and-location-data-law.

What Happened / Key Facts

Case background:

  • Respondent: Mitchell Miller, who “was convicted of possessing an unregistered still” and of other federal offenses.
  • Subpoenas: “agents from the Treasury Department’s Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms Bureau presented grand jury subpoenas issued in blank by the clerk of the District Court, and completed by the United States Attorney’s office” to the presidents of the banks where the respondent kept his accounts. “The banks did not advise respondent that the subpoenas had been served”.
  • Fifth Circuit: the Court of Appeals “reversed on the ground that a depositor’s Fourth Amendment rights are violated when bank records maintained pursuant to the Bank Secrecy Act are obtained by means of a defective subpoena”.
  • Supreme Court: “Since we find that respondent had no protectable Fourth Amendment interest in the subpoenaed documents, we reverse the decision below.”

The opinion of the Court:

  • Business records: the subpoenaed documents were not the respondent’s private papers; “these are the business records of the banks”.
  • Information revealed to a third party: “This Court has held repeatedly that the Fourth Amendment does not prohibit the obtaining of information revealed to a third party and conveyed by him to Government authorities, even if the information is revealed on the assumption that it will be used only for a limited purpose and the confidence placed in the third party will not be betrayed.”

Dissenting opinions, each filed separately:

  • Justice Brennan argued that disclosure to a bank is “not entirely volitional”. He relied on the California Supreme Court’s reading of its own constitution: “I dissent because in my view the California Supreme Court correctly interpreted the relevant constitutional language.”
  • Justice Marshall wrote: “Because the recordkeeping requirements of the Act order the seizure of customers’ bank records without a warrant and probable cause, I believe the Act is unconstitutional and that respondent has standing to raise that claim.”

Carpenter v. United States (2018) partial retreat (corrected against the slip opinion; see Correction below):

  • Facts: Prosecutors obtained court orders under the Stored Communications Act, not warrants, directing wireless carriers to disclose a robbery suspect’s cell-site records. The Government obtained 12,898 location points, including 127 days of records from one carrier.
  • Holding: “we hold that an individual maintains a legitimate expectation of privacy in the record of his physical movements as captured through CSLI”. The Court’s narrowest statement is that “accessing seven days of CSLI constitutes a Fourth Amendment search”, and it said the Government “must generally obtain a warrant supported by probable cause before acquiring such records”. Chief Justice Roberts’s opinion was joined by Justices Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan; Justices Kennedy, Thomas, Alito and Gorsuch dissented.
  • Limits stated by the Court: “Our decision today is a narrow one.” The Court wrote “We do not disturb the application of Smith and Miller” and “Nor do we address other business records that might incidentally reveal location information.” It said “we need not decide whether there is a limited period for which the Government may obtain an individual’s historical CSLI free from Fourth Amendment scrutiny” and expressed no view on real-time CSLI or tower dumps. Those questions are left open, not decided either way.
  • Effect: The third-party doctrine does not govern historical cell-site records compelled from carriers; Miller and Smith are left undisturbed for the records they covered.

Correction (2026-11-17)

See the corrections field above. Read against the Carpenter slip opinion, saved in cascade-research/documents.

Correction (2026-11-17, second pass: the Miller opinion itself)

The decision date in the earlier text was wrong; the opinion’s own date line gives April 21, 1976, and this entry’s filename, date field and text now carry it. The vote figure is removed: the opinion prints no tally, and its listing names the author, the Justices who joined, and the dissenters. Its sentence on information shared with a third party carries a qualification, so the earlier wording that the principle applied regardless of the circumstances is replaced by the opinion’s own words. The earlier text said the subpoenas were issued by the ATF; the opinion says ATF agents presented grand jury subpoenas issued in blank by the court clerk and completed by the United States Attorney’s office. It also said Justice Brennan’s dissent was joined by Justice Marshall; each filed a separate dissent. The line that the commercial data-broker industry operates in a space Miller opened, and that the government acquires from brokers what it could not obtain through primary surveillance, treated an open question as decided and is removed. Unsourced context paragraphs on ECPA, bulk metadata collection, FinCEN, the Right to Financial Privacy Act and later cases are removed pending sources; the related entries are linked below.

Sources & Citations

[1] United States v. Miller, 425 U.S. 435 (1976) — U.S. Supreme Court · Apr 21, 1976 Tier 1
[3] Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735 (1979) — U.S. Supreme Court · Jun 20, 1979 Tier 1
[4] Carpenter v. United States, 138 S. Ct. 2206 (2018) — U.S. Supreme Court · Jun 22, 2018 Tier 1
Tiers Tier 1 court records & gov docs · Tier 2 established outlets · Tier 3 regional & specialty press · Tier 4 opinion or single-source. Methodology →
Cite this entry
The Cascade Ledger. “Supreme Court Holds in United States v. Miller That a Bank Depositor Has No Fourth Amendment Interest in the Bank's Subpoenaed Records.” The Capture Cascade Timeline, April 21, 1976. https://capturecascade.org/event/1976-04-21--united-states-v-miller-bank-records-third-party-doctrine/